How PMM Gets More Out of Analyst Relations

How PMM Gets More Out of Analyst Relations

WRITTEN By Fluvio Lead consultant, Nick Moore

Fewer buyers are reading analyst reports. TrustRadius, now part of HG Insights, found that only 13% of technology buyers used an analyst report to inform a purchase, down 63% since 2022. The buyers making large, risky purchases pick up the phone instead. Gartner reports more than 510,000 direct client conversations a year.

Most analyst relations (AR) programs were built for the report. They exist to win a placement and announce it. Info-Tech Research Group estimates that only about a quarter of AR programs deliver measurable business value. The rest brief constantly and apply little of what analysts say back. 

Run that way, the program wins a placement and little else. The analyst hears what buyers won’t tell a vendor: who else is on the shortlist, and why you got cut. A program built for the report never learns either.


The Three Parts of an AR Program and PMM’s Role in Each

An AR program has three parts, the first of which is the briefing. A briefing is free. You present, the analyst listens, and they use what they hear to decide where you fit.

The second is the inquiry. Inquiries come with a paid subscription and run the other way: you ask and the analyst advises, the same way they advise buyers all day.

The third is the evaluation, the process behind a published report such as a Gartner Magic Quadrant or a Forrester Wave. You don't apply for one. Meet the inclusion criteria and you're scored, with or without your input.

Product marketing makes or influences most of what goes into all three, whoever runs the program.

The briefing deck is, in effect, a positioning document. A Forrester Wave asks vendors for a long questionnaire, a scripted demo, and reference customers, nearly all of which land on product marketing's desk.

The evaluation grades this work. More than half of a Gartner Magic Quadrant's 15 criteria sit on the “Completeness of Vision” axis, which covers market understanding, marketing strategy, offering strategy, and related criteria. What comes back is positioning intel, too: what buyers are asking, how competitors are seen, and whether your story holds up.

PMM doesn’t need to own the reporting line. It does need a say in which analysts the company invests in, what it asks them, what story it tells them, and where the answers go.

Each piece of an AR program was built for one use, and product marketing can put it to a second. The same briefing can test a positioning statement, and the same evaluation can hand you a competitor's weak points.

A Briefing Is a Positioning Exam

An analyst's job in a briefing is to work out where you fit so they know when to mention you. That takes four answers: who you're for, who you're not for, why you're different, and what proves it.

The analyst decides whether you’ve answered those four questions, and usually doesn’t say. So, treat the preparation as the first half of the exam. Good briefing content sits somewhere between the investor deck and the sales deck, and writing it forces strategic choices most companies never put on paper.

The second half is an inquiry a week or two later. Ask the analyst how they would describe you to a client. The distance between their playback and your positioning statement is the cheapest message test you’ll ever run.

The Inquiry Runs Both Ways

The analyst covering your category spends their time on calls with the people you sell to, hearing questions those buyers would never put to a vendor directly. Analysts hear about the deals you never knew existed, along with the reason you weren't invited.

An inquiry is your access to that, so ask specific questions:

  • What are buyers in our segment calling about this year? 

  • When our name comes up, who else is on the list? 

  • Where do we get cut, and why?

The inquiry is also where influence happens. In a briefing, the analyst is an audience. In an inquiry, they're advising, and that’s the moment they're open to being moved.

Use the inquiry to bring the analyst unfinished work: a draft positioning statement, or a category label you're weighing, and ask what buyers will hear. You get the critique, and the analyst gets a hand in shaping the story. People defend what they helped build, which is more persuasion than can reasonably be expected of a deck.

This also answers the typical objection to a “listening first” program, that the company still needs the placement. Asking is how the placement gets earned.

Tie each inquiry to a decision you're about to make, and give what you hear an owner: the PM weighing an integration, the enablement lead rewriting a battlecard. An inquiry that changes no decision was just a pleasant conversation.


Read the Report as an Objection List

Buyers may be reading the report less, but you should read it closely. The market definition and evaluation criteria are the analyst's synthesis of what buyers say they need. Forrester publishes every vendor’s score on each criterion, and Gartner lists strengths and cautions for each vendor. That makes the report a third-party scorecard of every competitor against buyer-derived requirements. Most vendors skim it for the graphic. A rival’s low scores and listed cautions belong in your battlecards.

Your own cautions deserve the most attention. Cautions are the negatives Gartner lists in each vendor's profile. At Forrester they show up as low scores. Assume they're what the analyst says about you on those private calls, which makes them objections your sales team is already hearing without knowing the source. Put each one into enablement with an answer, then build the proof that retires it.

Proof, to an analyst, means customers. Forrester interviews reference customers for every Wave. Gartner, having dropped formal references, leans on its own client calls and Peer Insights reviews. The advocacy and review programs product marketing already runs are how a caution gets retired. Arguing the score never does it. Analysts will correct facts, but they don't revise opinions under pressure.

All of this assumes you're being scored in the right evaluation. Which one that is turns out to be the biggest positioning decision in the whole program.

A Category Is a Budget Line

Gartner (and others) build their reports only after they see buyer demand for a category. So, each one is evidence that a budget line exists. A category of one has no budget line, which is why analysts won't put you in one. Vendors propose categories and analysts ratify them. Buyers fund the ratified version.

You can't opt into an evaluation and you can't opt out either. Meet the inclusion criteria and you get positioned, with or without your input. The input that counts arrives months earlier, as evidence about how buyers are buying: which incumbents your customers left, which requirements showed up in their RFPs. Over time, that evidence can move the criteria themselves.

Choosing which evaluation you want to be judged in is choosing whose budget you compete for, which makes it a positioning decision. The analyst's name for that category is the label on the budget line, so watch the vocabulary, too. If the words in your positioning doc never appear in the analyst's research, that gap is one of the clearest signs your positioning has expired.

This leaves a tension: to get a briefing accepted or clear the bar of inclusion, you have to describe yourself in the analyst's terms. Insisting on your own category name only makes the request easy to decline. Conform completely though, and you've accepted a frame built around the incumbents. The workable pattern is to enter under their label and argue for yours with buyer evidence, one inquiry at a time.

The Objections Worth Taking Seriously

Pay to play. 

Many PMMs assume placement follows spend. It doesn’t, at least not directly.

Briefings and evaluations are open to non-clients, and Gartner says its analysts accept briefings based on interest in the vendor, regardless of any contract. What a subscription buys is inquiry time.

That’s a fair thing to be uneasy about, because inquiries are where analysts get moved. So, be honest about what you're buying: access to the conversation that shapes opinion. Treat it as a research budget and judge it by how many decisions it informs.

Bandwidth. 

Andreessen Horowitz sizes an AR program at a quarter to a third of one person's time once a company has a paid analyst relationship. Much of that replaces research you’d otherwise do more slowly. It stays that small only if the analyst list stays short. Choose the analysts by asking buyers in win/loss interviews which outside advisors they consulted.

Continuity. 

Analyst relationships take years, and PMMs rotate across launches and products. Name one owner and leave them in place. As the company grows, that person becomes or hires the AR specialist.

Where to Start

If AR is already yours, pull two numbers: count last year's briefings against last year's inquiries, then count how many of those inquiries changed a decision anywhere in the company. If the second number is close to zero, you're running a program built for the report, and the fix is on your own calendar. Put an inquiry ahead of each positioning and pricing decision in the next two quarters.

If PMM simply isn’t involved today, “give us a say in analyst relations” is a tough ask. Instead, ask for the inquiry agenda. The team that runs AR can keep the scheduling and the press release when a report lands. Bring the same two numbers, because few teams will fight for hours they aren't using.

Somewhere this week, a buyer in your market will ask an analyst who they should be talking to. The analyst will answer with whatever they know about you, in whatever language they've settled on for your category. Product marketing can shape both.